No Crime to seek asylum - Irish migrant view of the Australian debate

  • user warning: Table 'cache_views_data' is marked as crashed and should be repaired query: SELECT data, created, headers, expire, serialized FROM cache_views_data WHERE cid = 'audio:block_1:results:ff0db4c55a037059c3695f66cdcd5d34' in /var/www/public/includes/cache.inc on line 27.
  • user warning: Table 'cache_views_data' is marked as crashed and should be repaired query: UPDATE cache_views_data SET data = 'a:3:{s:6:\"result\";a:6:{i:0;O:8:\"stdClass\":3:{s:3:\"nid\";s:4:\"1850\";s:10:\"node_title\";s:64:\"What Sort of Ireland Do We Want? debate between WSM, ISN, eirigi\";s:7:\"_random\";s:21:\"0.0010670376951499262\";}i:1;O:8:\"stdClass\":3:{s:3:\"nid\";s:4:\"6175\";s:10:\"node_title\";s:59:\"Céad míle fáilte to the IMF - protest song audio & video\";s:7:\"_random\";s:20:\"0.009595192977781587\";}i:2;O:8:\"stdClass\":3:{s:3:\"nid\";s:4:\"7679\";s:10:\"node_title\";s:68:\"Dare to struggle, Dare to win! A conversation with IWW Sydney -audio\";s:7:\"_random\";s:19:\"0.01088951808483295\";}i:3;O:8:\"stdClass\":3:{s:3:\"nid\";s:4:\"7617\";s:10:\"node_title\";s:61:\"Experiences of Anarchism in Ireland - talk at Jura in Syndney\";s:7:\"_random\";s:20:\"0.012957450945822012\";}i:4;O:8:\"stdClass\":3:{s:3:\"nid\";s:4:\"5818\";s:10:\"node_title\";s:57:\"Shell retreats as solidarity with Pat O\'Donnell continues\";s:7:\"_random\";s:20:\"0.019801224600338587\";}i:5;O:8:\"stdClass\":3:{s:3:\"nid\";s:4:\"5904\";s:10:\"node_title\";s:78:\"Will we see a revolution in our lifetime? - Audio from Rethinking Revolution 2\";s:7:\"_random\";s:20:\"0.020952269454442216\";}}s:10:\"total_rows\";i:166;s:5:\"pager\";a:5:{s:9:\"use_pager\";s:1:\"0\";s:14:\"items_per_page\";i:6;s:7:\"element\";i:0;s:6:\"offset\";i:0;s:12:\"current_page\";i:0;}}', created = 1565421997, expire = 1565422297, headers = '', serialized = 1 WHERE cid = 'audio:block_1:results:ff0db4c55a037059c3695f66cdcd5d34' in /var/www/public/includes/cache.inc on line 112.
  • user warning: Table 'cache_views_data' is marked as crashed and should be repaired query: SELECT data, created, headers, expire, serialized FROM cache_views_data WHERE cid = 'video:block_1:results:d1bd4a9bdf0c592395306e39f5452d02' in /var/www/public/includes/cache.inc on line 27.
  • user warning: Table 'cache_views_data' is marked as crashed and should be repaired query: UPDATE cache_views_data SET data = 'a:3:{s:6:\"result\";a:3:{i:0;O:8:\"stdClass\":3:{s:3:\"nid\";s:4:\"5276\";s:10:\"node_title\";s:57:\" Shell\'s Armada in Broadhaven bay, Rossport a video guide\";s:7:\"_random\";s:21:\"0.0007702056325694599\";}i:1;O:8:\"stdClass\":3:{s:3:\"nid\";s:4:\"8406\";s:10:\"node_title\";s:97:\"Video tour of previous Dublin eviction by injunction sites on the morning of Apollo House hearing\";s:7:\"_random\";s:20:\"0.004297352399953969\";}i:2;O:8:\"stdClass\":3:{s:3:\"nid\";s:4:\"8714\";s:10:\"node_title\";s:35:\"Dublin protests against Trump visit\";s:7:\"_random\";s:20:\"0.008224344819993103\";}}s:10:\"total_rows\";i:195;s:5:\"pager\";a:5:{s:9:\"use_pager\";s:1:\"0\";s:14:\"items_per_page\";i:3;s:7:\"element\";i:0;s:6:\"offset\";i:0;s:12:\"current_page\";i:0;}}', created = 1565421997, expire = 1565422297, headers = '', serialized = 1 WHERE cid = 'video:block_1:results:d1bd4a9bdf0c592395306e39f5452d02' in /var/www/public/includes/cache.inc on line 112.
  • user warning: Table 'cache_views_data' is marked as crashed and should be repaired query: SELECT data, created, headers, expire, serialized FROM cache_views_data WHERE cid = 'Random_PDF:block_1:results:d701b49486a84d4cd29efe1b1fbdd8e3' in /var/www/public/includes/cache.inc on line 27.
  • user warning: Table 'cache_views_data' is marked as crashed and should be repaired query: UPDATE cache_views_data SET data = 'a:3:{s:6:\"result\";a:2:{i:0;O:8:\"stdClass\":5:{s:3:\"nid\";s:4:\"6125\";s:10:\"node_title\";s:27:\"Irish Anarchist Review No 2\";s:21:\"node_revisions_teaser\";s:2596:\"<p>\r\n <span id=\"internal-source-marker_0.6484457798349057\" style=\"font-size: 11pt; font-family: Arial; color: rgb(0, 0, 0); background-color: transparent; font-weight: normal; font-style: normal; text-decoration: none; vertical-align: baseline;\"><img alt=\"IAR2\" src=\"/sites/default/files/images/Cover - Half.jpg\" style=\"width: 340px; height: 498px; border-width: 1px; border-style: solid; margin: 3px; float: right;\" /></span><span style=\"font-size: 11pt; font-family: Arial; color: rgb(0, 0, 0); background-color: transparent; font-weight: normal; font-style: normal; text-decoration: none; vertical-align: baseline;\">The Workers Solidarity Movement</span><span id=\"internal-source-marker_0.6484457798349057\" style=\"font-size: 11pt; font-family: Arial; color: rgb(0, 0, 0); background-color: transparent; font-weight: normal; font-style: normal; text-decoration: none; vertical-align: baseline;\"> is very pleased to announce the second issue of The Irish Anarchist Review</span><span id=\"internal-source-marker_0.6484457798349057\" style=\"font-size: 11pt; font-family: Arial; color: rgb(0, 0, 0); background-color: transparent; font-weight: normal; font-style: normal; text-decoration: none; vertical-align: baseline;\">. This magazine is dedicated to understanding the contemporary political, economic and social situation that confronts us, and finding ways to advance alternatives.</span></p>\r\n<p>\r\n <a href=\"http://www.wsm.ie/sites/default/files/Irish%20Anarchist%20Review%202.pdf\">Download The Irish Anarchist Review Issue 2</a><br />\r\n <br />\r\n <span style=\"font-size: 11pt; font-family: Arial; color: rgb(0, 0, 0); background-color: transparent; font-weight: normal; font-style: normal; text-decoration: none; vertical-align: baseline;\">Our first issue was released in the aftermath of major strikes across the public sector. Despite decades of partnership, a deflated union movement and an intense barrage of media bile, Irish workers showed their willingness to take to picket lines to fight the Government.</span><br />\r\n <br />\r\n <span style=\"font-size: 11pt; font-family: Arial; color: rgb(0, 0, 0); background-color: transparent; font-weight: normal; font-style: normal; text-decoration: none; vertical-align: baseline;\">Now, however, we can see that the union leadership were not willing to fight - they quickly demobilised strike action to return to the bargaining table, squeezing out a disgraceful deal in Croke Park negotiations. Now, without opposition, the Government calmly talks of four-years of &lsquo;hair-shirt&rsquo; budgets to restore the national finances.</span></p>\r\n\";s:21:\"node_revisions_format\";s:1:\"2\";s:7:\"_random\";s:19:\"0.01403001138384455\";}i:1;O:8:\"stdClass\":5:{s:3:\"nid\";s:4:\"5950\";s:10:\"node_title\";s:48:\"Dublin Anarchist Bookfair poster & leaflet PDF\'s\";s:21:\"node_revisions_teaser\";s:395:\"<p>\r\n <img alt=\"\" src=\"../../sites/default/files/images/AnarchistBookfair2010big.jpg\" style=\"width: 150px; height: 212px; margin: 3px; float: left;\" /></p>\r\n<p>\r\n The Dublin anarchist bookfair will take place 29th May in Liberty hall.&nbsp; Below are PDF files of the bookfair poster and a leaflet that you can print out and display / distribute to help with the promotion of the bookfair.</p>\r\n\";s:21:\"node_revisions_format\";s:1:\"2\";s:7:\"_random\";s:19:\"0.01838141402078924\";}}s:10:\"total_rows\";i:73;s:5:\"pager\";a:5:{s:9:\"use_pager\";s:1:\"0\";s:14:\"items_per_page\";i:2;s:7:\"element\";i:0;s:6:\"offset\";i:1;s:12:\"current_page\";i:0;}}', created = 1565421997, expire = 1565422297, headers = '', serialized = 1 WHERE cid = 'Random_PDF:block_1:results:d701b49486a84d4cd29efe1b1fbdd8e3' in /var/www/public/includes/cache.inc on line 112.
Date:

An Irish anarchist living in Melbourne, Australia gives his perspective on the 'asylum seeker' debate there leading up to the forthcoming elections. He argues Irish workers should be standing in solidarity with the most marginalised and dispossesed in our society. In the words of one Aboriginal activist; ' “As people who know what it’s like to be invaded by boat people we are in a better position to judge how the current boat people should be treated. Where the original boat people who took our country were armed to the teeth and bent on conquest, asylum seekers in 2012 are unarmed and seeking sanctuary."

If there is one thing our barbaric corrupt political class have in common from Ireland to Australia is the need when to keep us divided through the carrot and the stick. There weapon of choice is often whipping up of division, scapegoating of minorities and fear of the ‘other’. In the case of Australia, which I have learnt to well since arriving on these shores, it is the spectre of ‘boat people’ or asylum seekers which dominates the mainstream political discourse in terms of the forthcoming elections.  Basically two shades of the same political establishment seek to outgun each other to see who can offer the cruelest form treatment for men, women and children fleeing persecution, hunger and oppression.
 
You don’t need to dig deep beneath the surface to expose this racist and state sponsored terrorism which has tragically resulted in at least 1376 refugees drowning while trying to reach Australia since 1998. Behind every statistic lies an individual story and a family tragedy. Behind the hysteria of ‘queue jumpers’ and ‘crime influx’,  the reality is Australia takes less that 1% of the world’s refugees, people often fleeing conflicts and military occupations created by western imperialism such as those in Iraq and Afghanistan. For the vast majority of refugees there is no queue to join, especially when you are offered the choice of life and death.
 
In effort to ‘stop the boats’, both the Labour and coalition party policy believes asylum seekers should be 'processed' - illegally detained - in detention camps being built in Papua New Guinea who have been bribed and bullied by the Australian government. Until now people have been detained in some of the most isolated islands in the world at Christmas Island, the small island of Nauru and Manus Island.  They are detained in crowded and shocking conditions where rape, torture and suicide are rife, conditions that have been condemned by  international human rights groups and the UN.  A former security officer on Manus Island said; ‘I’ve never seen human being so destitute, so helpless and hopeless. In Australia, the facility couldn’t even serve as a dog kennel…I felt ashamed to be Australian.’ (1)
 
In an attempt to outgun the Labour Party and its ‘PNG Solution’, Tony Abbot, Catholic fundamentalist educated at Oxford and leader of the opposition claims he will completely stop permanent residency and use the Navy to stop the boats.  In this he is following in the footsteps of his predecessor, Thatcherite John Howard.
 
Drawing parallels between the past and present and use of the race card investigative journalist John Pilger correctly points out ‘In Australia race is all but genetically inscribed, as in apartheid South Africa. The federation of the Australia states in 1901 was founded on racial exclusion, white Australia policy and a dread of non-existent ‘hordes’ from as far away as Russia.  A 1940s policy of ‘populate or perish’ produced vibrant multiculturalism- yet a crude, often unconscious racism remains extraordinary current in Australian society and is exploited by a political elite with an enduring colonial mentality and obsequiousness to western ‘interests.’ (2)
 
This casual racism is something I have particularly noticed on the job and among family in terms of hostility to ‘asylum seekers’ and general fear of the other. While like any ‘community’, the Irish- Australian community is not one monolithic identity, I was struck, but to some extent not surprised, that many first and second generation have quietly assimilated into the colonial context of Australia. All too eager to fly the flag on Invasion Day on the 26 January while forgetting the similar circumstances which forced hundreds of people to flee Ireland due to oppression and poverty which continues to this very day in the form of economic migrants.
 
The irony of ‘boat people’ and how the tables have been turned has not been lost by some Aboriginal groups who welcome refugees. “As people who know what it’s like to be invaded by boat people, we are in a better position to judge how the current boat people should be treated. Where the original boat people who took our country were armed to the teeth and bent on conquest, asylum seekers in 2012 are unarmed and seeking sanctuary". Michael Mansell from the Aboriginal Provisional Government goes on “The ancestors of Kevin Rudd and Tony Abbot most likely came by boat. It is certain they never sought Aboriginal permission to enter our shores.”(3)
 
The other side of the story is an active refugee support movement that has gained some traction in recent months in terms of organising and mobilising, as well the eruption of riots and burning down of some camps.
 
Without forging real solidarity and having these discussions with your workmates and neighbours empathy and compassion can only sustain a movement for so long. In the face of largely indifference from the wider population and a colonial mentality from the political class, a class based movement must come to the forefront placing the needs and interests of people escaping persecution. While billions continue to spend on military conquests, border security and detention centres that could be better spent of alleviating poverty, job cuts and healthcare we see the interests of the profit come before people. Until we remove this cancer, refuge will always be one option and for many their only hope. In this regard Irish workers should clearly know what side of the fence they stand on.  
 
 
link for more info: http://www.refugeeaction.org.au/
 
Notes
 
1)http://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/australasia/asylumseekers-tortured-and-raped-at-australian-detention-centre-8730727.html
 
2)http://johnpilger.com/articles/australias-election-campaign-is-driven-by-a-barbarism-that-dares-not-speak-its-name
 
3)http://www.greenleft.org.au/node/54726

 

Comments

figures

1% of the worlds refugees are resettled AT ALL, EVER, by anyone. The proportion of refugees resettled in Australia is 0.009%. So yes, substantially less than one percent.

I'm not sure where you got the figure for the number of people who have drowned in Australian waters while seeking asylum, but it conflicts with others I have read.

re: figures

To the above commenter, please don't just make things up, hyperbole just makes the task of arguing against the current regime in Australia all the harder.

As at 31 December 2012 there were an estimated 45.2 million people displaced, of whom 10.5million fall under UNHCR mandate (Palestinians and internally displaced persons are outside it's purview). In 2012 Australia hosted 30,083 refugees under UNHC mandate, or 0.29% of the UNHCR mandate.

Australia received 29,610 applications for asylum in 2012, which represents 1.47% of a world total of 2,011,334 new applications in 2012.

For more check out the Asylum Seeker Resource Centre's fact sheets: http://www.asrc.org.au/resources/statistics/

Like what you're reading?
Find out when we publish more via the
WSM Facebook
& WSM Twitter